Head to Head includes singles and doubles results.
| 06/09/12 | Jim Stewart over Jay Cottman | 6-3; 6-4 | Playoff Match |
| 05/20/12 | Jim Stewart over Jay Cottman | 6-1; 6-3 | |
| 05/17/12 | Jay Cottman over Jim Stewart | 2-6; 6-4; 7-5 | |
| 07/11/09 | Jay Cottman over Jim Stewart | 7-6; 6-1 |
